← Resort Caddie

TRANSPARENT BY DESIGN

What our scores measure

We matched 68 individual course profiles to GolfPass review pages on September 16, 2026. These are external golf reviews, not our own firsthand editorial assessments.

Course ratings

We reproduce the source’s published overall rating and review count, plus its available conditions, layout, value, friendliness, pace, and amenities scores. We do not recalculate individual reviews or assume the source uses a simple average. Its aggregation period and category sample sizes are unspecified. Unrated categories are left blank, never treated as zero-star scores.

Resort golf composite

Each listed course with at least five source reviews receives equal weight. Add their published ratings and divide by the number of qualifying courses, then round to one decimal place. A resort must have at least two qualifying courses covering at least half the course lineup in this guide. Missing courses are excluded, never scored as zero. The five-review threshold is an editorial guardrail, not statistical proof of reliability.

Example: qualifying course ratings of 4.2, 4.6, and 4.9 produce (4.2 + 4.6 + 4.9) ÷ 3 = 4.6 / 5 after rounding. Review counts do not change course weights, so a popular course cannot dominate the entire resort score.

Category composites use the same qualifying courses where that category exists, with at least two course values required. The number of contributing courses is shown. Review totals count entries, not unique golfers; one person may review several courses.

Source handling

Every displayed course rating links to its original GolfPass page. GolfNow was checked, but the inspected Bandon listing showed no reviews; no GolfNow score was added. Potentially syndicated GolfNow/GolfPass reviews are not counted as separate datasets. Duplicate course listings and National nine-hole combinations were not added together.

GolfNow page checked ↗

Reddit trip reports are summarized with attribution and links. They are self-selected, unverified accounts, used only as qualitative context. Votes and comments never become star ratings. No external review is represented as feedback submitted to this website.

Limits and freshness

This is a dated research snapshot, not a live feed or representative survey. Ratings may include older course designs and playing conditions. A high score with few reviews should be treated cautiously. The lineup in this guide is not a complete or verified current inventory of each resort; coverage refers only to listed profiles. Confirm current course names, closures, access, and maintenance directly.

We do not yet score lodging, resort dining, spa, overall hospitality, or firsthand editorial quality. Original prototype scores and invented review totals have been removed. Changes require a fresh source check; no automatic refresh is currently scheduled.

Corrections

Use the feedback form on the relevant resort guide to flag a course mismatch or outdated information. Include the source link so it can be checked before publication.